Ok. That's IT.
I've officially had it with HGTV and the falsely-named 'Design Star' competition. Seriously, this is a waste of time, film, energy, resources, and brain cells - MY brain cells, because clearly NO ONE at the network knows what the hell to do with this Hot Mess {to use an overused phrase}. This is not design, these people are not designers OR decorators, the judges do not understand how to critique work for its own sake without imposing their own aesthetics on it, the people who are dreaming up the challenges are uninspired idiots, and anyone who thinks this is actually a competition to choose the best designer is sorely mistaken. {lest we not forget the Antonio Debacle last season} Each time I've watched it this season - not faithfully.... it's like pulling teeth, actually - I get more and more discouraged and disappointed with the entire thing.
I'd go on (and on), but someone else has already said it quite succinctly: Check out Debbie Dusenberry's post on her blog today at http://curioussofa.blogspot.com/2010/07/falling-star.html
Now THERE is a design judge, people!
I'd be the first to say let's put Deb on a judges' panel, along with other style icons (Elizabeth Maxon, perhaps, and Rachel Ashwell, Nate Berkus, and maybe even Jeff from 'Flipping Out' because he really is all about the details).
Then choose contestants that have experience in design - who said this needed to be a bunch of decorating neophytes, anyway? Get some breadth in the pool - store, visual, and event designers along with set designers (Antonio's one saving grace last season) as well as home decorators.
Show us inspiring ideas, cost- and time - conscious solutions to design dilemmas, make those challenges REAL ones, and let us HEAR the judge's deliberations so we can LEARN about great design principles. Get rid of the ridiculous theatrical music, dark stage with downspot lighting, and whispering judges. (That REALLY bugs me) Give us a crash course in real design each week, and show us the money. Period.
Mark Burnett, are you LISTENING to ANY of the feedback about this show this year??? Call me.This former 'Decorating & Display Diva' could offer you a few Hot Tips to fix it - before YOUR show is canceled. Or you are thrown off the island. {Oh, wait... that's your OTHER show.....}



